Avella requests probe of BSA over mosques 1

State Sen. Tony Avella has requested that a federal government review of the Board of Standards and Appeals for possible misconduct. The senator and others plan on filing a lawsuit to overturn the agency’s decision to approve variances for a mosque at the above lot in Flushing.

State Sen. Tony Avella (D-Bayside) again has sent a letter to U.S. Attorney of the Southern District Preet Bharara to review the Board of Standards and Appeals for possible improper conduct because its chairwoman appeared at the opening for a mosque that the agency approved.

The agency also recently approved a controversial mosque proposal at 46-05 Parsons Blvd. in Flushing and posted its decision eight weeks after deciding to grant all variances sought.

Avella sent a follow-up letter to Bharara on Sept. 29 about the original letter, which was sent on July 21, prior to the BSA’s decision on the Flushing mosque.

“My concern about this situation is whether or not there was any illegal conduct by the New York City administration with regard to BSA approving a variance and the appropriateness of the BSA Chair, whose responsibility it was to rule on the variance application presented by this mosque, to appear as a speaker at the opening of this facility,” Avella said in the original letter, referencing BSA Chairwoman Marjorie Perlmutter’s attending the opening ceremony for a new mosque in Sheepshead Bay. The prior BSA — which Perlmutter was not on, despite what Avella said, while three of the five current members were — denied an appeal to stop the mosque in 2011.

“In this situation with the mosque in Sheepshead Bay the specter of unlawful influence by the administration and partiality by BSA is raised when both the Mayor and Chair Perlmutter, on the Mayor’s behalf, played such a prominent role in the opening ceremony of this center,” the senator added.

Perlmutter also presented a proclamation from the de Blasio administration to the congregation of the Sheepshead Bay mosque at its opening.

Avella also expressed concern about the length of time used by the BSA to post the decision for the mosque.

“Now that BSA has rendered its decision to grant the variances and spent an unusually long time in writing the resolution, I am concerned as to whether the administration engaged in any form of improper conduct to influence BSA’s decision in this situation as it appears to have done in the Sheepshead Bay case clearly raising the specter of whether this process may not in fact be impartial,” the senator said in the follow-up letter.

Kissena Park Civic Assocation Vice President Carsten Glaeser has been vocally opposed to the BSA’s decision.

“I think their decision was not in line with the rules, the building codes that exist, they just rubber-stamped everything,” Glaeser told the Chronicle.

Variances for sky exposure plane, parking, side yard and floor area ratio were all granted to Masjid-e-Noor, the group behind the Flushing proposal.

“The Board of Standards and Appeals has a long history of not only not paying attention to the wishes of the community but also ignoring the facts in favor of helping developers and/or other entities get their variances even if they’re not deserved,” land use expert Paul Graziano said. “I welcome an investigation by the federal government into the way that the BSA is conducting themselves.”

Community Board 7 had rejected the application, saying that the programmatic needs for the mosque would not be met at the approximately 4,791-square-foot lot. The KPCA has also said that the programmatic needs will not be met.

“We told them that a building this size, it’s like putting a size 10 foot in a size two shoe; it’s not gonna fit,” CB 7 Chairman Gene Kelty said. “I may like the shoe but my foot is too big.”

Avella and others also plan on filing an Article 78 lawsuit to overturn the BSA’s decision.

“The Board of Standards and Appeals granted the request for a variance to waive bulk and parking requirements in an R2 zoning district at 46-05 Parsons Boulevard in Queens,” BSA Executive Director Ryan Singer said in an emailed statement. “The proposed mosque is eligible for religious deference under New York State law. The Board reviewed the case on its merits and the applicant illustrated to the Board over the course of three hearings that there would be no negative impacts on the surrounding area by granting the waivers. The granting of the variance was not unusual for institutions of this type, the Board granted 13 such variances to educational and religious institutions in 2015.”

According to Council on American Islamic Relations spokesman Ibrahim Hooper, opposition to mosque construction is often Islamophobic, although opponents of the Flushing mosque proposal have said that they are not against it because of the religion.

“We always hear that the opposition has nothing to do with it being a mosque or a school or a Muslim cemetery until you scratch the surface and you almost always find a level of anti-Muslim bias,” Hooper said.

The Office of the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District declined to comment.

Masjid-e-Noor could not be reached for comment.


(5) comments


Scepter or specter? I am confused by the use of scepter in the story. Granted, it is in 2 quotes, but is it the correct word?
Lastly, "The Officer of the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District declined to comment." I am thinking 'Office' is meant.

Rafick Bdaro

well you know......if this community is such an "Islamaphobed" ridden then re-locate your monstrosity of a project to other more "welcoming" communities. How's Bayside? or Little Neck? I think the problem is everytime something goes against a particular project of a group of minorities it is considered either "Racism" or "Religious Inclusion" PICK YOUR DAMN BOOK OF VARIANCES AND ZONING PAL! HOW CAN YOU TURN a 45 DEGREE ANGLE 1,000 SQUARE FOOT HOUSE INTO A SPRAWLING MOSQUE WITH SEVERAL FLOORS AND NO PARKING?!!!!!!! I Hope Avella exposes the corruption going on at the BSA and fine the crap out of them, including Masjid Al-Noor. Anyone from 11355 please let me know what can be done!


I wonder about the share volume of new mosques built over the past 20 years in Queens. Why do we have such a large influx of people of a religion with an anathema to Western culture settling in the midst of the heart of that evilness? And of those transplants, why are so many not making any attempt whatsoever to assimilate into our culture? Why do we see so many still walking around in burqas? Would an American woman be as ready to move to Saudi Arabia and get immersed in a culture governed by Sharia Law? I doubt it but we seem not to ask about the reversed scenario. Again, why is this happening? Perhaps there is a sinister explanation.... the Caliphate orchestrated by Middle Eastern wealth? And to think that our government may be facilitating this plot is to underline how naïve we as a people and nation have become.

Rafick Bdaro

Zargeo.....that is indeed a total paradox, but certainly like to focus on the issue at hand....They can not expect to build another mosque in an area or a property that is clearly not fit for that project, it is against the zoning in that area and the BSA should be blamed for providing variances. Hopefully, this project gets stopped.


Zargeo & Bdaro:

Here's why this is happening _


Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.